Since this is the last entry, I have decided to work on an all-time favourite movie of mine: The Lord of the Rings trilogy.
The following is an extract from the movie which made use of numerous communication theories in its presentation.
It shows the creature, Gollum, talking to the dark side of himself (yes, he's developed split personality). Let's just name them Gollum A, for his normal self, and Gollum B for his other self.
- Verbal/non-verbal communication
For instance, when Gollum A says "I hate you" to Gollum B, he says it with much agony on his face. From the diction, we know that A hated B; through affect display and facial expression(kinesics), we can tell how much he hated Gollum B.
- Cues/Perception
- The Knapp Model
Let's try applying it to the relationship between the main character of the movie, Aragorn, and one of the female leads, Eowyn.
Initiating:In this scene, Eowyn would swing her sword, throwing Aragorn's arm and knife to one side swiftly. Her face does not soften at his gaze.
(cautious and 'safe' feature of initiating stage)
This scene would see them having a somewhat self-disclosing small talk.
Dialogue:
Dialogue:
Eowyn: My uncle told me a strange thing. He
said that you rode to war with Thengel,
my grandfather. But he must be mistaken.
Aragorn: King Théoden has a good memory. He was only a small child at the time.
said that you rode to war with Thengel,
my grandfather. But he must be mistaken.
Aragorn: King Théoden has a good memory. He was only a small child at the time.
Eowyn: Then you must be at least 60? 70? But you cannot be 80!
Aragorn: 87.(self-disclosure)
Aragorn: 87.(self-disclosure)
When Aragorn comes back from battle, Eowyn could no longer hide her feelings; she hugs him with delight and relieve.
(Disclosure of feelings; physical contact)
Their relationship never hit the next stage of integrating due to Aragorn's commitment to his girlfriend.
Dialogue:
Aragorn: Why have you come?
Eowyn: Do you not know?
Aragorn: It is but a shadow and a thought that you love.I cannot give you what you seek.
These stages hence reiterate the fact that the Knapp Model is not linear; the stages in reality do not necessarily follow that of the model.
- Group Communication
We see, in the video, that some of the characters agree on destroying the One Ring while some do not. Boromir (the one who insists not to destroy the ring) and his followers are so confident that with the Ring, they could oust evil altogether, once and for all. This is obviously untrue as told by the other veterans. The actions of Boromir illustrated the illusion of invulnerability, believing in the group's own morality as well as the collective rationalisation qualities of groupthink. Such actions, if not ceased by the wise, could probably lead to severe outcomes which would damage the entire population in the movie.
- Intercultural Communication
The video shows how people in different cultures are met with impediments due to the difference in languages. As the culture of the various races are inherently different, it goes without saying that it affects the way they receive and interpret cues from members of other cultural groups. Being affected by their long history of unhappiness with each other, it has become a norm to hold prejudices and discriminate one another for dwarvish and elvish cultures. Such cultures would inevitably affect the communication between the races, usually in a negative way.
- The media
Finally, to end off, these are the official trailers of the trilogy. It is a truly fascinating movie.
For those who have not already watch it, please do. It is worth watching.
For those who had already watched it, might want to watch it again. :))
waoh...quite a gs summery of what we've learnt so far. i didn't watch this movie before but from your entry, i can see that this movie has alot of content. I would say that the way of filming by the producer would determine to a large extend the quality of the movie. Hence, i would think that from what you have illustrated in your entry, the storyline and effect of the movie contains a certain level of quality. Nice entry!
ReplyDeleteI think the intercultural communication section is pretty interesting.
ReplyDeleteYes, cultures play a huge part in movies as well. And it is the same thing in the movie as well; be sensitive to others' culture. Some races are not taught to be forgiving in their culture (like Orcs which you didn't mention). If you say something wrong to them, they might just cut off you head. So, beware what you say.
Wow..It's a long entry. Interesting and engaging though, how you applied your concepts on yet another thing you like.
ReplyDeleteI think you explained Gollum's parts very well. The concepts fit in nicely, making some real senses.
Couldn't see Eowyn's face in the picture with her holding the sword though. It is really nice nonetheless, genuine efforts!
I think there are lots of non-verbal cues used in all the 3 movies. The GOLLUM scene is one of them. It is outstanding how the director used them to create the 'crazy' constitute of the creature. It really made it eerier.
ReplyDeleteI think most filmmakers will pay attention to communication techniques when making a movie so that the audiences will be able to get what is the movie all about and enjoy it.
The producers did a good job in applying communication theories in their work.I think the theories you mentioned are appropriately applied to the movie.They really made use of a lot of different cues to bring out the desired effects.I also agree that the non-verbal cues are very important in creating the dark atmosphere of the scene with Gollum A and B.I think you could have also included the way that the director changed camera angles from one side to the other.He edited the scene such that it showed the different Gollums talking at each scene.This also help in communicating the darkness of Gollum to those watching the movie.I like your entry!
ReplyDeleteI still think that it is hard to apply models to relationships each of which is distinctly different from the other.
ReplyDeleteGroupthink is undesirable too. It often spoil a perfect event.